| Record 4381 View: Standard | Glossary HistCite Guide |
|
Author(s): BLACK AE; GOLDBERG GR; JEBB SA; LIVINGSTONE MBE; COLE TJ; PRENTICE AM
Title: CRITICAL-EVALUATION OF ENERGY-INTAKE DATA USING FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF ENERGY PHYSIOLOGY .2. EVALUATING THE RESULTS OF PUBLISHED SURVEYS
Source: EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CLINICAL NUTRITION 45 (12): 583-599
Date: 1991 DEC
Document Type: Journal : Article
Language: English
Comment:
Address: UNIV ULSTER,DEPT BIOL & BIOMED SCI,COLERAINE BT52 1SA,NORTH IRELAND.
Reprint: BLACK, AE, DUNN CLIN NUTR CTR,100 TENNIS COURT RD,CAMBRIDGE CB2
1QL,ENGLAND. Abstract: The fundamental principles of energy physiology were used to evaluate the validity of reported energy intake (EI) in 37 published dietary studies of adults providing 68 subgroups when classified according to sex and dietary method. EI was expressed as a multiple of BMR estimated using the reported heights and weights of the study populations (EI:BMR(est)). This ratio was compared with a study-specific cut-off value representing the lowest value for EI:BMR(est) that could, within defined bounds of statistical probability, reflect the habitual energy expenditure of a sedentary life-style. Mean EI:BMR(est) was 1.43 (0.19) compared with an expected requirement of 1.55. In 46 out of the 68 groups (68%), EI:BMR(est) was below the study-specific cut-off value. EI:BMR(est) was 1.37 (SD = 0.13) for women and 1.50 (SD = 0.16) for men (P < 0.001). This could reflect either better reporting by men or a more active life-style. When categorized according to dietary assessment method, 64%, 88% and 25% of results fell below the acceptable cut-off value for studies by diet records, diet recall and diet history, respectively. These data indicate that dietary assessment methods have a strong bias towards underestimation of habitual energy intake.
Cited References: 1968, CIRCULATION S1, V37 1979, VITAL HLTH STATISTIC, V11 1983, USDA PUBL 1983, VITAL HLTH STATISTIC, V11 1985, WHO TECH REP SERIES, V724 1987, VITAL HLTH STATISTIC, V11 1989, REP HLTH SOC SUBJ, V37, P75 ARAB L, 1982, ANN NUTR MET S1, V26 BAECKE JAH, 1983, AM J CLIN NUTR, V37, P278 BANDINI LG, 1990, AM J CLIN NUTR, V52, P421 BARASI ME, 1985, HUMAN NUTRITION APPL, V39, P189 BARKER ME, 1988, DIET LIFESTYLE HLTH BARKER ME, 1989, P NUTR SOC, V48, PA31 BARR SI, 1987, PROG FOOD NUTR SCI, V11, P307 BASIOTIS PP, 1987, J NUTR, V117, P1638 BEATON GH, 1979, AM J CLIN NUTR, V32, P2546 BINGHAM S, 1981, BRIT J NUTR, V45, P23 BINGHAM SA, 1987, NUTR ABSTR REV A, V57, P705 BLACK AE, 1984, HUM NUTR-APPL NUTR, V38, P165 BLACK AE, 1986, BRIT J NUTR, V56, P59 BLACK AE, 1991, P NUTR SOC, V50, PA108 BOGGIO V, 1986, CAH NUTR DIET, V21, P237 BOLTONSMITH C, 1991, P NUTR SOC, V50, PA117 BORGSTROM V, 1975, SCAND J MED S, V10 BRADDON FEM, 1988, J EPIDEMIOL COMMUN H, V42, P341 BULL NL, 1985, HUMAN NUTRITION A S1, V39, P1 CADE JE, 1988, BRIT MED J, V296, P1359 DIAZ E, 1991, P NATR SOC, V50, PA110 DIAZ E, IN PRESS AM J CLIN N FEHILLY AM, 1984, HUM NUTR-APPL NUTR, V38, P270 FEHILY AM, 1984, AM J CLIN NUTR, V40, P827 FEHILY AM, 1986, HUM NUTR-APPL NUTR, V40, P300 GIBNEY MJ, 1989, BRIT J NUTR, V61, P129 GOLDBERG GR, 1991, AM J CLIN NUTR, V54, P788 GOLDBERG GR, 1991, EUR J CLIN NUTR, V45, P569 GOLDBERG GR, 1991, P NUTR SOC, V50, PA8 HAGGARTY P, 1988, P NUTR SOC, V47, PA74 HALLFRISCH J, 1982, NUTR RES, V2, P263 HELMS P, 1982, NUTR CANCER, V4, P34 KANNEL W, 1978, UNPUB FRAMINGHAM STU KOINT F, 1987, MED NUTR, V23, P91 KROMHOUT D, 1983, AM J CLIN NUTR, V37, P295 LEE P, 1990, IRISH NATIONAL NUTRI LEMOINE A, 1986, ANN NUTR MET S1, V30 LENNER RA, 1977, ACTA MED SCAND, V202, P183 LICHTMAN SWP, 1991, AM J CLIN NUTR, V53, P23 LISSNER L, 1989, AM J CLIN NUTR, V49, P320 LIU K, 1978, J CHRON DIS, V31, P399 LIVINGSTONE MBE, 1990, BRIT MED J, V300, P708 LIVINGSTONE MBE, 1991, P NUTR SOC, V50, PA15 LIVINGSTONE MBE, IN PRESS AM J CLIN N LOGAN RL, 1978, LANCET, V1, P949 MARR JW, 1986, HUMAN NUTR APPLIED A, V40, P347 METZNER HL, 1977, AM J CLIN NUTR, V30, P712 NELSON M, 1986, BRIT J NUTR, V55, P267 PAPOZ L, 1982, AM J OBSTET GYNECOL, V142, P870 PRENTICE AM, 1986, BRIT MED J, V292, P983 PRENTICE AM, 1989, BRIT J NUTR, V62, P5 RUTISHAUSER IHE, 1979, BRIT J NUTR, V42, P33 SCHOFIELD WN, 1985, HUM NUTR CLIN N C S1, V39, P1 SCHULZ S, 1989, AM J CLIN NUTR, V49, P1146 SEALE JL, 1990, AM J CLIN NUTR, V52, P66 SEMPOS CT, 1985, AM J EPIDEMIOL, V121, P120 SEPANEN R, 1982, NUTR CANCER, V4, P40 STUNKARD AJ, 1985, J PSYCHOSOM RES, V29, P71 THOMSON M, 1982, HUM NUTR-APPL NUTR, V36, P272 THOMSON M, 1985, HUM NUTR-APPL NUTR, V39, P44 THOMSON M, 1988, AM J CLIN NUTR, V47, P139 VANSTAVEREN W, 1985, THESIS U WAGENINGEN VANSTAVEREN WA, 1986, AM J EPIDEMIOL, V123, P884 WESTERTERP KR, 1986, J APPL PHYSIOL, V61, P2162 WESTERTERP KR, 1991, INT J OBESITY S3, V15 |